It is possible that your other Oscar is more timid then the other. As a result, the other Oscar tries to take advantage of the situation and bully the other Oscar. Thus, seeing the other Oscar timid, the other Oscar snatches its share of the food, making the other Oscar lose more food making it thin. I once had 2 Oscars and the one was timid and the other was slightly bigger and more aggresive. I was in the same situation as yours. Another possibility is that your water has problem i cant tell as i hav not seen anything. Oscarfishlover will be able to help u with this.