OK, Here is what you need to do... Go back to Petsmart, or Petco, or where ever and buy a Liquid Test kit. API is the brand. You can test for ammonia, nitrite, and Nitrate,and PH.
These reading will tell us a lot.
how big is your filter? how often do you do a water change?
My best advice would be to rehome the tinfoils as they get HUGE. Your tank is only big enough for one oscar.
I would bet your levels are off, and there is some fin nipping going on. When we get your water sorted, your oscars fins will heal nice and quick.