Welcome to the site. Ahh..... the $64,000 question, how long should you wait before splitting them up? I think it's really up to your discretion. If they carry on fighting and one of them is obviously the weaker one taking all the beating and getting severe injuries, you will have to decide when to split them up. Do you wait and see what happens, or just split them up? A real difficult one that we will find it difficult to answer for you unless we could observe your Oscars for a period of time. Personally, if they were fighting all the time and didn't spend any time with each other, I would split them up. If they did hang around with each other more than they actually fought, I would just give it a little more time and just hope that it settles down. Sometimes Oscars can receive what looks like a really nasty injuries, if you keep the water in good condition, these injuries normally heal up very quickly