"and when you change the cartriges you lose a substancial amount of bio media. with the aquaclear filter you never lose any of the beneficial bacteria."
not entirely true, you dont lose much as its its a 3 stage filter using 2 cartridges,
the blue carbon filter is both mechanical and carbon filtration.
the second cartridge is a bio filer you never replace or clean. this is where your bacteria live.
it works great for me,i use this filter on 3 aquariums. not sayin its the best but it does work very well and for a 55 gallon tank that cost 50 bucks i cant justify a 300 dollar canister filter.