Yes, if your tank has a big enough footprint.
I've seen the combo in many other tanks.
At least 6'x2'x2'(2,5 wide is even better)
The longnoses spook easier than the Floridas, though.
I say Florida's for 99% of all Gars sold as spotted are actually Florida.
Longnose feeding can be more of a pain for their longnose makes it harder to fit preyfish into their mouth.
edit: i don't know if you plan on keeping the longnoses with the oscars, if you do their skittyness may have them run into the walls of your tank and do damage to their beaks and spines.Feeding will be an even bigger problem, with hungry o's.
Florida are a better option, for they're more tough and spook less easily,imo.