Yes, this tank should be cycled, I lost my Oscar about 2 weeks ago now, I've done a 50% water change last weekend, and the only thing that is in the tank is a pleco and a pictus cat. I have a piece of driftwood/bogwood in there for the pleco, it's been in there for quite some time, probably 4-5 years. The only other thing that is in there decoration wise is a structure for the pictus to hide in and that's it.
The test kit that I have is by Aquarium Pharmaceuticals, and it's a Master Test Kit. It tests for ph (6.0 to 7.6) High Range ph (7.4 to 8.8) Ammonia, Nitrite, general hardness and carbonate hardness. I used the High Range ph test, should I have just used the regular ph one instead? Again, I don't have a test bottle for nitrates, so that wasn't done. Maybe I used the wrong ph test bottle?
Just went and did the regular ph-WOW!!! It was 7.6 or higher.

NOW how do I get this conundrum solved?